Welcome to Gage and Tollner
Gage and Tollner, nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, revitalizes classic American cuisine with an upscale flair. This iconic establishment marries a romantic ambiance with modern amenities, such as outdoor seating and a full bar, creating an inviting atmosphere for all. With a focus on dinner and dessert, their menu offers a selection that caters to various tastes, including limited vegetarian options. The attentive waiter service adds to a memorable dining experience, while the warmth of the space, enhanced by happy hour specials, makes it perfect for gatherings. Gage and Tollner is not just a meal—it's a celebration of culinary heritage.
- 372 Fulton St Brooklyn, NY 11201 United States Hotline: (347) 689-3677
Welcome to Gage and Tollner, a beacon of American culinary excellence nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201. This historic gem seamlessly blends a rich past with modern sensibilities, inviting diners to experience a world where exceptional food meets charming ambiance.
As you step through the doors, you’re greeted by an intimate and romantic setting, perfect for a date night or a celebratory dinner with friends. The atmosphere strikes a balance between classy and upmarket while maintaining a warmth that's welcoming. Notably, Gage and Tollner is not just about the ambiance; it’s about the dining experience.
- Reservations: Easily secure your spot with their reservation system.
- Menu Highlights: The menu offers a variety of dishes with limited vegetarian options, showcasing the creativity and skill of the kitchen staff.
- Dining Options: Whether you prefer to dine in, take out, or enjoy a lovely delivery, Gage and Tollner caters to your needs.
- Special Features: Outdoor seating is available, complete with heated and covered options for those seeking to enjoy their meal al fresco, even in less-than-perfect weather.
- Catering & Happy Hour: For those looking to host an event, their catering options are exquisite, and keep an eye out for delightful happy hour specials!
What truly sets Gage and Tollner apart is its commitment to providing not just a meal but a memorable experience. The thoughtful service, characterized by attentive waitstaff and a full bar offering a wide selection of drinks, elevates every visit. Dogs are welcome, making it a pet-friendly destination amidst the bustling city life.
During my visit, I was struck by the exquisite flavors of the dishes. Each plate was meticulously prepared, reflecting both refinement and comfort. The desserts, a true highlight, were an indulgent way to conclude the meal, leaving me yearning for just one more bite.
Gage and Tollner encapsulates not just a dining experience but a celebration of American cuisine that respects tradition while embracing the modern palate. With its subtle yet inviting ambiance, it’s a perfect venue for groups, couples, or anyone looking to enjoy a delectable meal in an incredible setting.
For inquiries or to make reservations, feel free to call (347) 689-3677. Discover the delightful journey that awaits at Gage and Tollner—where history and gastronomy collide beautifully!

Gage Tollner is legit. The place has this oldschool, classic vibe thats hard to come by these dayswood paneling, gas lamps, the whole deal. It feels upscale but not pretentious. The oysters were fresh, the shecrab soup was killer, and ...

Friendly staff, excellent service and delicious food. I got to try caviar for the first time here celebrate my friends 21st birthday. Staff went above and beyond to accommodate our requests. 1010

The food is good and I would go back. The service we received was basic. But you cant choose your server. We were celebrating a birthday and I asked for the dessert we ordered to come with a candle. Even though the card on our table said ...

Four of us went to this restaurant for dinner on a Saturday night. Our reservation was early 530 and by the time we left, about two hours later, the place was packed. ...

My husband and I went in on a whim this past Thursday night. We were greeted warmly and sat at the bar which is spacious and really comfortable. We were primarily served by Gary, who is an absolute GEM of a human being. I cant sing his ...

The cinnamon roll we enjoyed today was exceptional Tender dough, plenty of cinnamon filling and amazing buttercream on top. The biscuits and gravy were very good as was the fried chicken. Were really nailing our healthier eating in 2025 resolution, arent we?!

What an experience! I love the way the restaurant has been restored. Upon entering, youre transported to early 1900s NYC. The wait staff are attentive and kind. ...

Old school esthetics. Very unique vibe to itself compared to other steakhouses I have been. Our servers were supers nice as well as the host. The manager also check in on us which is always a plus. Food overall was incredible and to the ...